| Motion | Ruling | Rationale | |--------|--------|------------| | (defense) | Denied (Oct 2022) | The DNA sample was collected under a valid search warrant based on probable cause. | | Exclusion of “dying declaration” (defense) | Denied (Jan 2023) | Court held that Payton’s last recorded 911 call (transcribed at 07:55) meets the statutory criteria for a dying declaration under Tex. Code Crim. Art. 38.03 . | | Motion to dismiss aggravated kidnapping | Denied (Mar 2023) | The prosecution demonstrated “force, threat, or deception” per Art. 20.02, as the victim was restrained in the back of Dalton’s truck. |
The trial began in 2023, with the prosecution presenting a case that emphasized Preslee's alleged motive and intent. The defense argued that the death was an accident and that Preslee was not responsible for Trevizo's injuries. payton preslee case
The case drew significant media attention due to its shocking nature and the seemingly calm demeanor of Preslee during her 911 call. Many people were outraged by the alleged brutality of the crime and the fact that Preslee appeared to show little emotion when reporting the incident. a 28‑year‑old local construction worker
The is a high‑profile homicide investigation that began with the disappearance of 17‑year‑old Payton Preslee from Midland, Texas , on June 14, 2021 . The case culminated in the conviction of James “Jimmy” Dalton , a 28‑year‑old local construction worker, for first‑degree murder, aggravated kidnapping, and aggravated assault. The trial, lasting five months, was notable for the extensive use of digital forensics, the introduction of newly‑adopted “cell‑site‑analysis” statutes, and a controversial “dying‑declaration” testimony. for first‑degree murder
During the investigation, prosecutors presented various pieces of evidence, including: